The Mother Divine
Change Font Size 
 Home
CONFUSING REALITIES
By John Warne
Excerpts from Virtuous Reality: An Introduction to Vedanta by Swami Dayananda Saraswati


The discriminative inquiry of Vedanta undertaken by a qualified student ends in the knowledge that is truth. The inquiry leads to the knowledge that atma, the self, exists, and all else is not-atma, anatma. The student does not create or change anything with his appreciation of the concept that all objects of awareness are anatma. He is formulating the discovery of the nature and reality of atma and the dependent nature of anatma. The discriminative inquiry into truth is required because there is confusion, a mix-up. Recognition of the confusion is part of the teaching. As a result of that problematic notion, taking oneself to be an individual with attributes, the person comes to include self in anatma. He sees himself as one among the countless living beings. He seems separate from every other member of his species, and each of them is not he. The experiential conclusion that each entity is distinct and as real as oneself forms the basis of fear, anxiety, and samsara, the futile process of becoming. The individual’s crippling sense of limitation, his sense that he is the conclusions he has about his shortcomings, is centred on the indiscriminate “I” consciousness, on the unreasoned belief that one is one among many. The individual’s confusion comes from a mistaking of two different orders of reality. The effect for the individual is like standing in a room full of mirrors and counting himself as one of the reflections. If the person is the one who is not a reflection, then he is the truth (Sanskrit: satyam) of all the reflections. The reflections are dependent on his presence. That which has reality only as dependent on something else is termed mithya in Vedanta.

Only from a perspective of counting members of a set, the set of individual human bodies, can a person include himself and conclude his lack of wholeness. He has included self in the set of things he counts in the world. Counting is wrong if it confuses orders of reality. If the individual does not count according to reality, that which he is not overwhelms him; that which he is not impinges on him with its immensity. With the individual’s physical and mental limitations, how can he come to terms with all he confronts outside his body? The problem of appearing infinitely small in a world that is infinitely big is enormous. The individual’s thinking bespeaks self-consciousness, unjustified comparison, self-criticism, searching, struggling, and feeling small. He sees each entity as discrete, as true and as impermanent as he is. Yet, the individual may come to question the usual way of counting and so move away from the arithmetic that inevitably ends up in confirmed duality, separation, and a sense of isolation.

By grace and by internal inquiry, the student discovers the impropriety of counting himself as one of the impermanent objects in the world. He ends up with a certain doubt. With an appreciation of another possibility - beyond frustration and inadequacy - comes a search for a different kind of experience. His room fills with books on the Tao, and Yoga, mystics, Don Juan, Tibetan Buddhism, and Sri Ramakrishna. But what he is seeking is still an experience. That sense of separation between what he has and the experience he does not have is always there. Even if he has had an experience that was free of a sense of duality, does it extend to knowledge of his being the non-dual whole? Enlightenment is either confirmation of a sense of inadequacy, because one seeks that enlightenment, or it is an abiding appreciation of immediate - not imminent - wholeness. In absolute reality there is no duality at all. Within the empirical and subjective realities, duality is the experience but not the truth. All experience comes and goes within that unchanging consciousness - the absolute reality that is self, atma, the unity that accommodates all duality. The man in the room of mirrors may recognize there is no duality, that there is only the one. Changing the way one counts oneself is the rejection of duality through understanding. That is the only way to eliminate duality. In fact, there is no duality. There is only atma. Anatma does not enjoy the same order of reality as atma. The confusion is a misunderstanding of orders of reality. That which one experiences needs to be understood differently.

Swami Dayananda often uses the example of gold ornaments. If a person has one hundred golden ornaments of different size and form, he can count them. A jeweller created these one hundred golden ornaments - earrings, bangles, studs and necklaces - from one pound of gold. Each type of ornament is distinctive, has its own use and location, and is not confused with the others. The necklaces do not look like the studs or earrings and so on. From a linguistic perspective, ‘ornaments’ is the substantive, and gold is an attribute of the ornaments. In terms of the syntax, gold appears to be a variable factor, while the ornaments enjoy a nominal permanence. But what is the underlying, permanent entity? If one counts metals, one order of reality, there is one thing there - gold. It is the unchanging gold that appears in the different, changeable, forms. Because the person counted one gold does not mean that instead of one hundred, there are now ninety-nine bangles, chains, and earrings. After counting the one metal, gold, there is nothing really to count. One gold plus the one hundred equals one gold. This does not deny the existence of the ornaments. It is understanding the nature of the ornaments and of the underlying reality which is the gold.

When a person looks at all the ornaments, he sees the gold. When he sees the ornaments, his knowledge of the gold is not displaced by the ‘ornament’ knowledge. When he focuses on one of the chains, he has ‘chain’ knowledge. Then, switching to an earring, ‘earring’ knowledge replaces ‘chain’ knowledge. Within one order of reality, one perception replaces another. Two independent units that are of the same order of reality - for example, an earring and a bangle - cannot occupy the mind at once, for there is the perception of earring and the perception of bangle. But ‘gold’ knowledge never goes, irrespective of which ornament the person picks up. The gold is the substance, satyam, that underlies and pervades the ornaments which are the attributes. The gold is what is there, and the ornaments exist only as names and forms. In the Vedantic inquiry, the attributes are understood in terms of reality as mithya: they are dependent for their existence on the substance. The student needs two different words in terms of realities to explain the nature of what is self and what not-self. Only then is there comprehension of what is there.

There needs to be a further distinction. Satyam is that which exists; mithya is that which depends on a substance for its existence; tuccham is that which does not exist. The horn of a man does not exist. The words ‘horn’ and ‘man’ have satyam and meaning. But the meaning of the compound ‘man's horn’ does not exist - the object is tuccham. Grammatically the compound is correct, but it is an impossible combination, a contradiction in terms. A person may see a castle in the clouds, but even as he sees it he knows it is not satyam. He knows it is purely imagination. It is tuccham: the castle does not exist. The object is not there, and it is a false perception. It is not empirically there, but one may and can take it as if it were. Even so, it is false.

The objects in a dream are not tuccham. As long as the person is under the spell of the dream, the dream objects do exist. But upon waking, he finds the objects of the dream are false. If, while walking in the shadows, a person mistakes a rope for a snake, the snake has satyam for the time being. It is able to make the person jump and run or freeze. But the snake of the rope is neither real nor dependent on the rope - the snake is false. False means that the object is not physically there, but the person takes it as if it is there. The snake is neither real nor unreal. All activities in this world are based on a person’s knowledge of these three categories: satyam (that which is true), mithya (that which has no existence separate from its substance), and tuccham (that which is false). When a person sees on the sand a shiny shell that looks like a coin, there is movement on his part towards it and then disappointment. Can he be disappointed without false judgment? The person responds to what is false until he knows it is false. The discovery chagrins him as well. He is sorry it was not a coin, and he is sorry he went for what was not there. Only those things which one considers existent can be sources of desire, pursuit, fear, and disappointment.

Think of a shirt as another way to understand satyam and mithya. The shirt is not non-existent: the word shirt has meaning and the object, the shirt, is useful. The shirt is not imagined, thus not false. The shirt appears to be satyam. But the shirt is made of cloth, cotton fabric. The fabric is satyam. The ‘fabric’ knowledge and ‘shirt’ knowledge do not represent two discrete objects. ‘Fabric’ knowledge does not replace ‘shirt’ knowledge in the mind. There is only one object, and ‘satyam’ was used up on the shirt. Yet fabric is satyam and has meaning. There are two words and one object. There is a confusion of realities.

In order to have the term satyam available for the fabric, you cannot just change the classification of the shirt to non-existent. You cannot give the fabric and the shirt the same order of reality. The confusion is for want of a word. If you remove the stitches, there will be no shirt - there will be fabric. Before the creation of the shirt, and then while the shirt exists, and then even when the shirt no longer exists, there will be fabric. You must use satyam to describe the reality of the fabric. What about the shirt? You need the word mithya. There is no equivalent in English: apparent will not work. That which is mithya is neither delusion nor illusion. Mithya is that which is not independent of something else, that which has no independent existence apart from something else.

Vedanta says that atma, the self, awareness, is satyam, and all else is mithya. Everything else depends on atma, and atma does not depend on anything else. You cannot imagine, much less create, a shirt without fabric or some stuff. The shirt depends on the fabric. You can imagine an elephant going into your ear: either you make the ear big or the elephant small. But you cannot imagine a shirt that is not made of something. The shirt does not exist without being dependent on something else. The ornaments do not exist independent of the gold. That which is there before, during, and after creation is satyam. That which comes and goes is mithya. Anything that is created is mithya. This leaves the student with a curious appreciation: creation is mithya; satyam is not dependent on creation; yet where the mithya is, there the satyam is. The student need not, and cannot, remove the mithya to get to the satyam which is the underlying reality: where the shirt is, there the fabric is.